Question

deeper analysis:

1. what emotions do you think shakespeare is trying to evoke in his readers? provide specific lines from the poem as evidence for your answer.

1. what can you infer about the relationship between shakespeare and the person he is addressing in this sonnet?

creative response:

1. imagine you are tasked with writing a modern version of \sonnet 18\. pick a modern analogy (instead of a summers day) to compare someones beauty to or any topic. write 4 lines in the style of shakespeare using your chosen analogy. share with the class and explain your choices.

Explanation:

⚡ Using what you learned: close reading methods for poetic texts

Step 1: Analyze Question 11 (Evoked Emotions in Sonnet 18)

To identify the emotions Shakespeare evokes in Sonnet 18 ("Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?"), we look at the progression of the poem:

• Awe and Admiration: The speaker begins by comparing the beloved to a summer's day, but immediately notes that the beloved is "more lovely and more temperate."
• Melancholy/Anxiety about Time: The middle lines focus on the fleeting nature of summer and youth ("And summer's lease hath all too short a date," "And every fair from fair sometime declines").
• Triumph and Hope: The final lines shift to a triumphant tone, declaring that the beloved's beauty will never fade because it is preserved forever in the poem ("But thy eternal summer shall not fade," "So long as men can breathe or eyes can see, / So long lives this, and this gives life to thee").

Step 2: Analyze Question 12 (Inference about the Relationship)

We can infer several key aspects of the relationship between the speaker and the addressee:

• Deep Affection and Devotion: The speaker holds the addressee in incredibly high regard, viewing them as superior to the most beautiful season of the year.
• Protective and Immortalizing Love: The speaker wants to protect the addressee from the ravages of time and death. By writing the sonnet, the speaker is offering a gift of immortality, showing a deep, enduring commitment that transcends physical aging.

Step 3: Draft Creative Response for Question 13 (Modern Analogy)

We need to replace the "summer's day" analogy with a modern equivalent of beauty, consistency, and comfort (e.g., a perfectly curated playlist, a reliable Wi-Fi connection, or a warm cup of coffee on a rainy day). Let's use the analogy of a perfectly warm, comforting cup of coffee on a rainy morning to represent warmth, comfort, and consistency.

• Modern Analogy: A warm cup of coffee on a rainy morning.
• 4-Line Poem (Shakespearean Style/Iambic Pentameter):

Shall I compare thee to a morning brew?

Thou art more warm, more sweet, and far more bright;

Cold rain may fall and grey the sky anew,

But thy sweet warmth brings back the morning light.

• Explanation of Choices: The analogy of a morning coffee represents comfort, warmth, and a sense of starting the day with peace. While a rainy morning can feel gloomy and cold, the presence of the beloved (like the warm coffee) completely counteracts the coldness of the world, offering reliable comfort and joy.

---

Answer:

Question 11

Shakespeare evokes feelings of profound admiration and triumphant hope. Initially, he establishes admiration by stating the beloved is "more lovely and more temperate" than a summer's day. He then transitions from the melancholy fear of aging to a feeling of triumph over death, using the lines: "But thy eternal summer shall not fade" and "So long as men can breathe or eyes can see, / So long lives this, and this gives life to thee."

Question 12

We can infer that the relationship is one of deep devotion, intense love, and artistic celebration. The speaker does not just admire the addressee's physical beauty; they want to rescue them from the destructive power of time. By writing this poem, the speaker seeks to immortalize the addressee, showing a selfless desire to make the beloved's memory live on forever.

Question 13

• Modern Analogy: A warm cup of coffee on a rainy morning.
• 4-Line Poem:

Shall I compare thee to a morning brew?

Thou art more warm, more sweet, and far more bright;

Cold rain may fall and grey the sky anew,

But thy sweet warmth brings back the morning light.

• Explanation: I chose a warm cup of coffee on a rainy morning because it represents comfort, energy, and peace when the outside world is gloomy. Just as coffee warms you up on a cold day, the beloved's presence brings light and comfort to the speaker's life.