Question

evaluating an authors style

which statement is an evaluation of mortimers writing style?

using really academic language and second-person point of view is the best way to make a book about going back in time.
mortimers use of academic language and the second-person point of view support his purpose of sharing information about elizabethan england.
in the time travelers guide to elizabethan england, mortimer uses academic language and second-person point of view.
the academic language and second-person point of view of mortimers writing create an authoritative tone.

Explanation:

Understand the goal of evaluation

An evaluation of writing style must go beyond merely describing the style elements (such as point of view or vocabulary). It must analyze and judge how those stylistic choices function to achieve a specific effect, tone, or purpose. This connects directly to our understanding of Authorial Style and Writing Strategies.

Analyze the given options

• Option 1: "Using really academic language and second-person point of view is the best way to make a book about going back in time." This is a subjective opinion about what is "best" rather than an objective evaluation of Mortimer's specific text.
• Option 2: "Mortimer's use of academic language and the second-person point of view support his purpose of sharing information about Elizabethan England." This statement connects the stylistic choices directly to the author's purpose, which is a key component of rhetorical evaluation.
• Option 3: "In The Time Traveler's Guide to Elizabethan England, Mortimer uses academic language and second-person point of view." This is a purely descriptive statement of fact, not an evaluation.
• Option 4: "The academic language and second-person point of view of Mortimer's writing create an authoritative tone." This statement evaluates how specific stylistic choices function together to construct a particular tone, which is a core aspect of analyzing Authorial Style.

Determine the best evaluation statement

While Option 2 connects style to purpose, Option 4 provides a more precise stylistic evaluation by explaining the direct rhetorical effect (creating an "authoritative tone") of Mortimer's specific choices (academic language and second-person point of view). Evaluating how style shapes tone is a fundamental standard of literary and rhetorical analysis.

Answer:

• (A) Using really academic language and second-person point of view is the best way to make a book about going back in time.
• (B) Mortimer's use of academic language and the second-person point of view support his purpose of sharing information about Elizabethan England.
• (C) In The Time Traveler's Guide to Elizabethan England, Mortimer uses academic language and second-person point of view.
• (D) The academic language and second-person point of view of Mortimer's writing create an authoritative tone. (Correct answer)