Question

Question was provided via image upload.

Explanation:

Identify the main claim

The writer's main thesis is that Brutus symbolizes loyalty due to his commitment to Rome.

Define a counterclaim

Using Literary Analysis, a counterclaim must directly oppose or challenge this main thesis.

Evaluate the first option

"Nevertheless, some may argue..." directly opposes the loyalty claim by highlighting his disloyalty to Caesar.

Evaluate the remaining options

The other options support Brutus's commitment to Rome rather than presenting an opposing viewpoint.

Answer:

• (A) Nevertheless, some may argue that the disloyalty Brutus shows to his friend Caesar diminishes his character. (Correct answer)
• (B) While Brutus is a friend of Caesar's, he is concerned about the future of Rome.
• (C) Brutus specifically states in his speech to the people of Rome that he acted in the best interest of Rome.
• (D) As a result, Brutus agrees to the conspiracy against Julius Caesar.