Question

question 4

which provides an example of a pathetic fallacy?

amlochan had made up a number of stories in defense of chantara\
\seemed like a person lovingly carved out of a shining, black stone\
\trees whose roots clawed the empty air like fingers desperately outspread to clutch something firm\

Explanation:

🆕 New Concept Discovered: Pathetic Fallacy
Giving human emotions to nature

Step 1: Understand "Pathetic Fallacy"

Pathetic fallacy is a specific type of personification where human emotions, feelings, or sensations are attributed to inanimate objects in nature (like weather, trees, rocks, or the environment).

Step 2: Analyze the Options

• Option 1: "Ramlochan had made up a number of stories in defense of Chantara"
• This describes a human action (making up stories) performed by a human (Ramlochan). There is no personification or attribution of human feelings to nature.

• Option 2: "Seemed like a person lovingly carved out of a shining, black stone"
• This is a simile comparing a person to a carved stone. It does not attribute human emotions to nature.

• Option 3: "Trees whose roots clawed the empty air like fingers desperately outspread to clutch something firm"
• This sentence describes trees (nature) having roots that "clawed" and were "desperately outspread to clutch something." The word desperately attributes a strong human emotion and state of mind (desperation) to a part of nature (the trees and their roots). This is a clear example of pathetic fallacy.

Answer:

"Trees whose roots clawed the empty air like fingers desperately outspread to clutch something firm"