QUESTION IMAGE
Question
study this cartoon and review the section entitled “economic equity” on page 26 before answering the questions below.
cartoon with four panels:
- man: “we just want to give the biggest breaks”
- man: “...to those who pay the most taxes!”
- man: “what could be fairer than that?”
- worker with hammer: “giving the biggest paychecks to those who do the most work?” man: “you’re not from here, are you?”
copyright © 1999 by joel pett, lexington herald - leader. all rights reserved.
- identifying central issues what economic questions does the cartoon raise?
- drawing inferences (a) typically, who pays the most taxes in american society?
(b) which of the speakers favors tax breaks for the wealthy?
- making comparisons what does the man with the hammer think is the fairest way to divide the economic pie?
- recognizing bias which point of view does the cartoonist suggest is more commonly held by americans? explain your answer.
- drawing conclusions why might people’s opinions about what is fair differ?
Question 1
The cartoon presents two views on economic fairness. One view is giving tax breaks to those who pay the most taxes (likely the wealthy), and the other is giving the biggest paychecks to those who do the most work (likely workers). So the economic questions raised are about what is the fair way to distribute economic benefits (like tax breaks or income) and who should receive them (based on tax payment or work effort).
In American society, typically, the wealthy (high - income earners, including business owners, high - salary professionals, etc.) pay the most taxes in terms of the total amount of taxes paid, although they may have a lower effective tax rate in some cases. They have higher incomes and more assets, so their tax liability (especially in terms of income tax and capital gains tax) is often the largest in absolute terms.
The man in the suit (the first three - panel speaker) says that the biggest breaks should go to those who pay the most taxes (which are likely the wealthy). The man with the hammer has a different view. So the speaker in the suit (the one who says “We just want to give the biggest breaks... To those who pay the most taxes! What could be fairer than that?”) favors tax breaks for the wealthy.
Snap & solve any problem in the app
Get step-by-step solutions on Sovi AI
Photo-based solutions with guided steps
Explore more problems and detailed explanations
The cartoon raises questions about what constitutes economic fairness in distributing benefits (like tax breaks) and who should receive them—whether it should be those who pay the most taxes or those who do the most work.