QUESTION IMAGE
Question
Question was provided via image upload.
Analyze the question prompt
The question asks: "What counterclaim is presented in the passage?"
Examine the source passage
The passage is an excerpt from Mohandas Gandhi's "Quit India" speech:
"There is a chorus of disapproval and righteous protest all over the world against us. They say we are erring, the move is inopportune..."
Identify the counterclaim
A counterclaim is an opposing argument or point of view.
Gandhi states: "They say we are erring, the move is inopportune."
Here, "we" refers to the Indian independence movement, and "the move" refers to seeking immediate independence ("Quit India").
Therefore, the critics' claim (the counterclaim) is that India is making a mistake or acting at the wrong time by seeking independence now.
Evaluate the given options
- Option 1: "India is making a mistake by seeking independence."
This directly aligns with "They say we are erring, the move is inopportune."
- Option 2: "India should not be limited to nonviolence."
This is not mentioned as a global protest or counterclaim in this excerpt.
- Option 3: "The British are unlikely to grant India's independence."
While a potential obstacle, this is not the specific "chorus of disapproval" or accusation of "erring" described in the opening lines.
Formulate the final selection
The first option is the correct representation of the counterclaim presented in the passage.
Snap & solve any problem in the app
Get step-by-step solutions on Sovi AI
Photo-based solutions with guided steps
Explore more problems and detailed explanations
- India is making a mistake by seeking independence. (Correct answer)
- India should not be limited to nonviolence.
- The British are unlikely to grant India's independence.